A leading Australian priest who sexually preyed on a disabled and
vulnerable woman on Sydney's north shore for 14 years has been allowed
to return to preaching and running community groups at one of the
nation's busiest churches.
The recent decision by the Catholic Church to allow Father Tom Knowles
to return to full duties at St Francis' in Melbourne's central business
district after about 16 months of "administrative leave" has outraged
his victim and victims' groups.
Father Knowles's reinstatement comes after the church apologised to
Jennifer Herrick, paid her $100,000 in compensation and acknowledged
"the harm that can be caused to vulnerable people in such a case".
Ms Herrick's story highlights a rarely exposed facet of church abuse:
vulnerable adult parishioners who are targeted by their priest for a
While the case falls outside the royal commission on child sex abuse
because she was 22 when the sexual relationship began, her lawyer, Peter
Karp, said: "The adult victims [of clergy abuse] are voiceless
Psychologists say such relationships may be compared with those in which
doctors have sex with vulnerable patients, while a professor of
theology at the Australian Catholic University, Neil Ormerod, believes
there may be hundreds of similar cases yet to emerge.
Ms Herrick was a shy 19-year-old with bilateral congenital hip dysplasia
- a condition causing her to walk with a highly abnormal gait - when
her family's priest, Father Knowles, cultivated a relationship with her
at his church, Our Lady of Dolours, in Chatswood. Ms Herrick's later
psychological reports say she was being groomed.
When Ms Herrick turned 22, Father Knowles, who was then 30, unexpectedly
initiated intercourse with her, an act she describes as unpleasant and
painful but one she felt powerless to stop because of his position. It
was the first time Ms Herrick had had sex.
For the next 14 years, Father Knowles maintained a secret sexual relationship with Ms Herrick.
"I now understand that my very severe vulnerability allowed him to
exploit me by abusing his priestly powerful position for nearly two
decades for his sexual needs,'' she said.
In 2011, after she lodged a formal complaint, a confidential church investigation found his conduct to be highly inappropriate.
Ms Herrick allowed Father Knowles - who as a Catholic priest is meant to
be celibate - to have sex with her during a 14-year period and told no
one about it. The sex was often hurried, aggressive and sometimes
She withdrew from friends and family and grew increasingly anxious,
ultimately having a breakdown and losing her promising career as a high
"You feel you can't say anything to anybody because he was a priest.
When a young, disabled woman is caught up with a priest, you are
trapped,'' she said.
"I was denied an opportunity to develop normally as a young adult. I
could never test out other relationships or have a family. It was a
personal and pastoral betrayal."
In a report, Ms Herrick's psychologist, Ana Grant, said the priest's
conduct had caused Ms Herrick serious post traumatic stress disorder and
fell "within the criteria for clergy perpetrated sexual abuse".
In September 2011, Father Knowles's superior, Father Graeme Duro, wrote
to Ms Herrick acknowledging that she had "endured a great deal of
emotional and psychological pain and suffering and that Fr Knowles's
inappropriate conduct was to your detriment".
But last month, a senior NSW church official, Michael Salmon, advised Ms
Herrick's lawyer in writing that Father Knowles had "committed to a
prolonged, regular and very intensive and personally confronting
programme of therapy" and he would "return to full community life, and
to public ministry".
Ms Herrick described the decision as "extremely distressing".
Father Knowles was photographed preaching to parishioners last week at
St Francis', which hosts 10,000 parishioners a week. In his career with
the church, Father Knowles has been appointed as the head of an order
and held other senior roles in NSW and Victoria.
Mr Karp has acted for many clergy sexual abuse victims.
"Vulnerable people in Jennifer's position give their trust to a priest
on the understanding that this trust will be returned," he said. "In
this instance, the victim is so aggrieved, you would think that justice
would demand that he be stood down permanently."
Father Duro said last week: ''We express our deep regret at the hurt
suffered by the complainant and the harm Fr Knowles's behaviour has
caused his fellow religious and the church; we believe everything … to
alleviate the complainant's suffering and to address Fr Knowles's
responsibility for his actions has been done and it is appropriate for
him to return to public ministry.''
Professor Ormerod, who has supported Ms Herrick, said that in
reinstating Father Knowles the church sent a "signal to the victim that
her situation wasn't serious" when in fact the abuse of trust by the
priest had been extensive.
Professor Ormerod said he suspected the number of adults abused or in
inappropriate relationships with their priests might be greater than the
child abuse scandal.
A victims' advocate, Chris McIsaac of Broken Rights, said: ''A
psychiatrist who targeted a patient sexually could face deregistration,
so why not a clergyman?''